Computing Reviews
Today's Issue Hot Topics Search Browse Recommended My Account Log In
Review Help
Search
Multimedia document presentation, information extraction, and document formation in MINOS: a model and a system
Christodoulakis S., Theodoridou M., Ho F., Papa M., Pathria A. ACM Transactions on Information Systems4 (4):345-383,1986.Type:Article
Date Reviewed: Sep 1 1987

MINOS is an information system that provides integrated facilities for creating and managing multimedia objects. Implemented on a SUN workstation equipped with an addressable analog speech storage device, it accommodates documents comprising any mixture of text, image (raster and structured), and voice. Multimedia documents are created, modified, filed, retrieved, browsed, and archived within the system. All operation is online (no hard copy).

MINOS has an object-oriented model of multimedia documents that permits parts to be shared between documents. It also includes version management to assist in working with several versions of documents. Objects may be in the editing or archived states; in the latter case, they are not modifiable. MINOS includes a text editor (UNIX “vi”) and an image editor, and will include a voice editor.

The user is able to retrieve information through query specification, browsing through documents, and browsing within documents. Queries can operate not only on the text part of a document, but also on the image and voice parts; however, only the caption and data type can be searched. Queries can also specify presentation information such as position on the page.

The authors mention presentation modes such as browsing, zooming, transparencies, narration, voice segments, annotations, and process simulation. Browsing is by page number, section number, and word search; bookmarks are available. Transparencies allow annotations to be overlaid on images. Narration is different from voice segments because it begins automatically when a certain point in the document is reached, while specific action must be taken to hear voice segments. So-called “annotations” are links to independent multimedia documents. Process simulation is scripted animation by fast page turning.

Since it is not designed to fulfill any stated requirements, it is difficult to evaluate the MINOS architecture. It is by no means clear to this reviewer how, or whether, such a system would be used in practice. Despite its length, the paper does not really indicate how flexible the system is (to take a simple example, can tables--which are a kind of image--contain text? pictures?). None of the components seem particularly novel; the emphasis is on getting it all together. But the system seems to suffer from creeping featurism. What are its goals, and what does the architecture exclude? Given that all the parts exist, what are the research problems that are being addressed? This paper gives no clear answers to these fundamental questions.

Reviewer:  Ian H. Witten Review #: CR111503
Bookmark and Share
 
Systems And Software (H.3.4 )
 
 
Office Automation (H.4.1 )
 
Would you recommend this review?
yes
no
Other reviews under "Systems And Software": Date
Browse and navigate: an advance in database access methods
Noerr P., Bivins Noerr K. Information Processing and Management: an International Journal 21(3): 205-213, 1985. Type: Article
Feb 1 1986
Managing organizational innovation: the evolution from word processing to office information systems
Johnson B., Rice R., Columbia University Press, New York, NY, 1987. Type: Book (9789780231063982)
Oct 1 1988
Behavioral evaluation and analysis of a hypertext browser
Egan D., Remde J., Landauer T. (ed), Lochbaum C., Gomez L. ACM SIGCHI Bulletin 20(SI): 205-210, 1989. Type: Article
Mar 1 1990
more...

E-Mail This Printer-Friendly
Send Your Comments
Contact Us
Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.   Copyright 1999-2024 ThinkLoud®
Terms of Use
| Privacy Policy